Button finished in a tie for fifth at the 2013 NCAA Division III Men's Golf Championship and helped guid the Pirates to a tied for 14th in the team competition. The junior, who held the individual lead after the first two rounds, finished the tournament with a four round score of 290 (70-67-78-75).
Charles finished in a tie for 12th place and was just three shots back of Button. Charles carded a four round total of 293 (74-73-74-72). In addition to his PING All-America honors, Charles was one of just 30 golfers from across the country to be named a Cleveland Golf/Srixon All-America Scholar.